Quad9 to withdraw its DNS resolver from France after court penalties, Cloudflare says

Quad9 to withdraw its DNS resolver from France after court penalties, Cloudflare says

Cloudflare has published a blog post about the decision by Quad9, a Swiss non-profit foundation, to withdraw its free public DNS resolver (9.9.9.9) from France. According to Cloudflare, Quad9 announced the move last month. It followed months of litigation and a French court ruling that imposed daily financial penalties on Quad9 for failing to block domains associated with alleged copyright infringement. Cloudflare describes the choice facing Quad9 as crippling litigation and penalties on one side, or changing its service in a way that would undermine users' privacy and security on the other. Quad9 chose to leave.

Cloudflare says Quad9's resolver is used in France by a wide range of individuals and organizations, including government bodies, educational institutions, hospitals and utilities. Because the service is built to preserve privacy, Quad9 does not know who its users are and cannot notify them directly. Cloudflare warns that anyone who does not change resolver before the service is removed will find their Internet failing with no explanation, and that this is likely to cause immediate and potentially severe disruption. The problem is worse for devices such as security systems or thermostats that are hardwired to use Quad9. Cloudflare says fixing those may be slow or even impossible.

The post says Quad9 is not the first public resolver to leave a country over blocking orders. Cisco previously withdrew its OpenDNS resolver from France, Portugal and, temporarily, Belgium under similar circumstances. A Belgian court has now issued an order that would impose substantial penalties on Cloudflare, Google and Cisco if they do not begin blocking websites through their public resolvers by early January 2027. Cloudflare says it has never done that. Together with Google and Cisco it has appealed the Belgian order, and it hopes for a resolution before the end of the year.

Most of the post is Cloudflare's case against requiring public resolvers to block. It explains DNS as the Internet's address book and a resolver as the service that looks up the address. Cloudflare launched its own public resolver, 1.1.1.1, in April 2018 and says it does not collect any user data. Its arguments: blocking is ineffective, because a resolver can only decline to return an IP address and cannot remove content or take down servers, and a user can get around a block in less than a minute by switching to one of the thousands of other resolvers, or skip resolvers entirely if they know the IP address. Cloudflare says blocking may add friction for some users, but there is no evidence it reduces total online infringement. It is also a blunt instrument: DNS works at the domain level, so a resolver cannot block one infringing video or file and must block the whole domain, legal content included. The user gets no explanation, just a site that fails to load. And public resolvers operate globally, so one country's order could decide what is reachable worldwide. Cloudflare notes that the EU-dedicated resolver DNS4EU, operated by Whalebone, blocks in response to country-specific orders but does so across the entire EU. Re-engineering resolvers for localized blocking, it argues, would hurt performance, resilience and privacy.

Cloudflare says that it, Google, Cisco and Quad9 have all opposed mandated blocking, with some success. Courts in Germany ruled in favor of Cloudflare and Quad9 several years ago and rejected requests to require DNS blocking. More recently, a French court rejected penalties against Cloudflare for not blocking through 1.1.1.1, finding that other actions taken through its CDN and reverse-proxy service were enough to comply with the underlying order. Quad9, as a small non-profit offering only a public resolver, had no such alternative way to show compliance, so the French court granted rightsholders' request for penalties.

Cloudflare acknowledges that rightsholders have a legitimate interest in preventing piracy, but argues they are aiming at the wrong layer. It cites a recent study, which it does not name, that found most online piracy in Europe is hosted in Europe, and says the better target is the hosting providers that store the pirated files. It also argues that pushing out established resolvers sends users back to ISP defaults (which may monetize browsing data), to lesser-known or anonymous resolvers, or to running their own, and that this especially costs users of services like Quad9 that also protect against phishing and malware. Cloudflare hopes Quad9's exit will be a wake-up call to rightsholders and policymakers.

Key facts

  • Quad9, a Swiss non-profit, announced last month that it will withdraw its free public DNS resolver from France after a French court imposed daily financial penalties for not blocking domains tied to alleged copyright infringement.
  • Cloudflare says Quad9 is used in France by government bodies, schools, hospitals and utilities, cannot notify them, and that their Internet will fail without explanation if they do not switch resolver in time.
  • A Belgian court order would penalize Cloudflare, Google and Cisco if they do not begin blocking through public resolvers by early January 2027; the three have appealed, and Cloudflare hopes for a resolution before year end.
  • Cloudflare argues resolver blocking is easy to bypass in less than a minute, blocks whole domains rather than single files, and has no evidence of reducing total infringement.
  • Cisco earlier withdrew OpenDNS from France, Portugal and, temporarily, Belgium; a French court spared Cloudflare from penalties for 1.1.1.1 because its CDN and reverse-proxy actions were deemed sufficient.

Why it matters

A public DNS resolver is basic Internet infrastructure, and this is a case of one being forced out of a country by court-ordered penalties rather than by its own choice. Cloudflare presents it as a precedent: Cisco has already pulled OpenDNS from France, Portugal and temporarily Belgium, and a Belgian order now targets Cloudflare, Google and Cisco themselves. The post's title calls Quad9's exit a canary in the coal mine. The underlying question is whether rightsholders can require resolvers, and not only hosts or sites, to block domains.

Who it affects

French users of Quad9, which Cloudflare says include individuals, government bodies, educational institutions, hospitals and utilities. Devices hardwired to Quad9, such as security systems and thermostats, are singled out as hard to fix. Beyond France, the operators of other public resolvers (Cloudflare, Google, Cisco) and users in Belgium face the pending Belgian order. Rightsholders and policymakers pressing for blocking at every layer are the audience Cloudflare is addressing.

How to use it

This is an analysis, not a product. The practical point is for anyone in France who relies on Quad9 (9.9.9.9): the post says users must change their resolver before Quad9 removes its service, or their Internet will fail with no explanation. The alternatives it lists are other public resolvers such as Cloudflare's 1.1.1.1, Google's 8.8.8.8 and Cisco's OpenDNS, the ISP's default resolver, lesser-known resolvers, or running your own. Organizations should check for hardwired resolver settings on devices. The post says changing a resolver is easy.

How solid is it

The facts about Quad9's withdrawal and the French ruling come from Cloudflare's own blog post, not from Quad9's announcement or the court decision. Cloudflare is also a party with a direct stake: it opposes DNS blocking mandates and is appealing the Belgian order. The post does not give the size of the penalties, the rightsholders, the name of the French court or the Belgian court, or the date Quad9's withdrawal takes effect. The study on European piracy hosting is cited without a name. Claims such as the lack of evidence that blocking reduces infringement are Cloudflare's own argument.

Risks and caveats

Cloudflare says removal of Quad9 is likely, not certain, to cause immediate and potentially severe disruption; how many users are actually caught out is not stated, and no figure for Quad9's French user base is given. The advocacy is one-sided: rightsholders' side of the case is described only briefly, though the post does grant that they have a legitimate interest in preventing piracy. The Belgian appeal is pending, and Cloudflare only hopes for a resolution before the end of the year.

“Penalizing transparent services only pushes users toward less accountable corners of the web.”

— Cloudflare, blog post on Quad9's withdrawal from France