Big school districts weigh dropping Google Search over Gemini

New York, Los Angeles and Chicago schools are considering alternatives to Google after the company said it will disable Search for schools that opt out of its AI features, according to The New York Times, as relayed by The Verge. Starting next year, schools will not have the option to disable Gemini-powered features without also disabling Search.
Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, told the Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated," and that schools that turn off Google's AI features "will not have access to Search."
Many elected officials, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders, responded harshly, calling Google's behavior "extortion." The Verge notes that Mamdani had recently announced a policy that barred 2-K-8 students from using AI in the classroom. In a statement to the Times, New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said: "If Google doesn't reconsider their position, we will explore other search options." Chicago's public schools have also reportedly told Google that if it cannot provide a version of Search without AI, "the district will look to other search solutions."
In a statement to The Verge, Google spokesperson Laura Breen said Google hears parents' and teachers' concerns about students using AI to shortcut learning and shares the goal of helping students learn. She said Google is starting to pilot Guided Learning capabilities in Search this month, meant to walk students step-by-step through a range of complex problems instead of just giving quick answers. She added that next year Google is also updating its approach to school controls to address educators' feedback, so the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until schools decide which services to enable. Breen said Google is building these experiences in partnership with educators.
The Verge adds context: educators are wary of AI's effect on students' critical thinking skills, and some studies have shown that students who use AI generally perform worse on tests. There are also concerns about the mental health effects on children who develop relationships with chatbots at a young age. But Google is deeply embedded in classrooms across the US, which rely on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other services, so going fully Google-free might prove difficult.
Key facts
- New York, Los Angeles and Chicago schools are considering Google alternatives, according to The New York Times.
- Starting next year, schools will not be able to disable Gemini-powered features without also disabling Search; Google's Chris Phillips said "Search and AI are deeply integrated."
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders, among many elected officials, called Google's behavior "extortion."
- Google's Laura Breen said Guided Learning in Search is being piloted this month, and next year the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until schools choose which services to enable.
- The Verge notes that Google Classroom and Chromebooks are widely used in US classrooms, so going fully Google-free might prove difficult.
Why it matters
Google's rule joins two things schools may want to treat separately: AI features for students and the search engine they use every day. Large districts are now publicly saying they could leave Search over it, and many elected officials have used the word "extortion." The dispute also lands as educators worry about AI's effect on critical thinking and as some studies have shown that students who use AI generally perform worse on tests.
Who it affects
Schools and districts on Google's education products, including New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago, which are named as considering alternatives. Students, teachers and administrators who rely on Search in class are affected too. Officials such as Mayor Zohran Mamdani, whose recent policy barred 2-K-8 students from using AI in the classroom, and Senator Bernie Sanders have criticised the move.
How to use it
For school administrators, the practical points from the report are these. Starting next year, turning off Gemini-powered features also turns off Search. Google's spokesperson says that next year the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default until a school decides which services to enable. Google is also piloting Guided Learning capabilities in Search this month, aimed at walking students through complex problems step-by-step rather than giving quick answers.
How solid is it
The core report comes from The New York Times, relayed by The Verge. The Verge also received a direct statement from Google spokesperson Laura Breen, and the quotes from Google's Chris Phillips and New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels are attributed to statements given to the Times. The Chicago position is reported with the word "reportedly." No statement from Los Angeles officials is quoted; only New York and Chicago are quoted. The studies on AI and test performance are not named.
Risks and caveats
Considering alternatives is not the same as switching. The Verge says going fully Google-free might prove difficult because of Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other services used across US classrooms. The source does not say which alternative search providers districts are considering, and it does not say how many students or schools are affected. Google's account of default-off controls next year sits beside the Times report that schools cannot disable Gemini features without also losing Search, and the source does not reconcile the two.
“If Google doesn’t reconsider their position, we will explore other search options.”
— Kamar H. Samuels, New York City schools chancellor, in a statement to The New York Times