FCC orders California to stop enforcing phone service rules against AT&T
The Federal Communications Commission has ordered California to stop enforcing its Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) rules against AT&T. Ars Technica describes the order as another battle between the Trump administration and California over the state's right to enforce its own telecom laws and regulations.
Under those rules, AT&T's status as a Carrier of Last Resort in California requires it to offer telephone service to any potential customer in its territory. AT&T wants to stop offering basic phone service to new customers and to discontinue service for 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers on June 1, 2027.
The order, released on the day of the report, granted AT&T's request to preempt state rules. It follows an earlier FCC approval of AT&T's petition to discontinue service. AT&T had tried to get the same result in court, but a federal judge rejected its request to override California's rules in July.
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr said in a statement released with the order: "California’s Carrier of Last Resort framework may have made sense when it was established 30 years ago. But those rules were designed for a bygone era and no longer make sense in today’s competitive, advanced marketplace." He added that the FCC has granted AT&T's applications to replace legacy voice service with a modern, IP-based alternative in certain areas of the state, and that California's requirements are blocking AT&T from proceeding with a federally authorized transition.
The dispute turns on what replaces the old copper lines. If AT&T ends service on them, many homes and businesses would not be offered modern fiber networks. AT&T claims a wireless home phone service that connects to the cellular network will be good enough, and the FCC agreed. California says its rules do allow wireless replacements if they meet the state's standards for basic phone service, but that AT&T must demonstrate its wireless service would meet the COLR obligations. Those requirements include flat-rate options for unlimited voice calls, discounted Lifeline rates for eligible low-income customers, and telephone relay service for people who are deaf and hard of hearing.
California has stood alone against AT&T, which has received relief from COLR obligations in 20 of the 21 states in its wireline service territory. The FCC order probably is not the last word, since California could sue the commission.
Key facts
- The FCC ordered California to stop enforcing its Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) rules against AT&T, granting AT&T's request to preempt state rules.
- AT&T wants to stop offering basic phone service to new customers and discontinue it for 184,000 residential and 15,000 business customers on June 1, 2027.
- AT&T already has relief from COLR obligations in 20 of the 21 states in its wireline territory; California is the exception.
- A federal judge rejected AT&T's request to override California's rules in July; the FCC order granting preemption followed its earlier approval of AT&T's petition to discontinue service.
- California says wireless replacements are allowed if they meet state standards, including flat-rate unlimited calling, Lifeline discounts and relay service; it could sue the FCC.
Why it matters
The order pits federal telecom authority against a state's own rules. It follows a failed attempt by AT&T to get the same result in court: a federal judge rejected its request to override California's rules in July. The FCC route succeeded where that one did not. California was the last of the 21 states in AT&T's wireline territory where AT&T lacked relief from COLR obligations, so the order removes the final holdout.
Who it affects
AT&T's basic phone customers in California are the most directly affected: 184,000 residential and 15,000 business customers are slated for discontinuation on June 1, 2027. Customers who rely on the state's requirements, such as flat-rate unlimited voice calling, discounted Lifeline rates for eligible low-income customers and telephone relay service for people who are deaf and hard of hearing, have a stake in whether any replacement service meets them. California regulators are affected too, as their enforcement power over AT&T is cut back.
How to use it
This is a regulatory story rather than a product. For AT&T copper-line customers in California, the date to watch is June 1, 2027, when AT&T wants to discontinue service. The replacement AT&T proposes is a wireless home phone service that connects to the cellular network. The source does not give pricing or terms for it.
How solid is it
The report rests on the FCC order and on Carr's statement released with it, and it quotes him directly. The numbers (184,000 residential and 15,000 business customers, 20 of 21 states, June 1, 2027) come straight from the article. The outcome is not final: the article says California could sue the commission. The article quotes no AT&T or California statement on the order.
Risks and caveats
The two sides disagree on whether wireless can stand in for copper. AT&T says it will be good enough, and the FCC agreed. California says AT&T must demonstrate that its wireless service meets the COLR obligations. The article also notes that if AT&T ends service on its old copper lines, many homes and businesses would not be offered modern fiber networks. A court challenge by California is possible, so the June 1, 2027 date is not locked in by the order alone.
“California’s Carrier of Last Resort framework may have made sense when it was established 30 years ago. But those rules were designed for a bygone era and no longer make sense in today’s competitive, advanced marketplace.”
— Brendan Carr, FCC Chairman