TechCrunch's AI graveyard lists failed products, from Character.ai to Ollie

TechCrunch has put together a running "AI graveyard": a list of notable AI products, startups, launches and bets that have shut down, pivoted or significantly missed expectations. It opens with two recent cases. Chatbot platform Character.ai filed for bankruptcy just five years after launching, and the privacy-focused assistant Ollie announced its shutdown a few weeks ago. The piece cites S&P Global Market Intelligence, which says about 42% of AI initiatives are ultimately abandoned by their corporate parents. The reasons vary: insufficient funding, technical challenges, competition, difficulty scaling, or weak user demand. TechCrunch frames the list as a record of what these attempts can teach the industry, not a scorecard of flops.
OpenAI gets the first section. On July 9 it updated ChatGPT into a broader "super app" with separate Chat, Codex and Work modes, and renamed the familiar version "ChatGPT Classic". Users found the new interface confusing and cluttered, and OpenAI rolled the change back soon after. The company has had better luck folding stand-alone apps into ChatGPT. ChatGPT Atlas, a stand-alone AI web browser, lasted less than a year before it was discontinued on August 9, with its most useful features absorbed into ChatGPT. Operator, an agent that could browse the web and complete tasks for a user, got the same treatment. Image generation has increasingly moved into ChatGPT too, shrinking DALL-E's role as a separate destination. Sora, the video-sharing platform, struggled with high operating costs and user-retention problems and shut down in March 2026.
Apple's Siri AI is the delay story. When Apple unveiled Apple Intelligence in 2024, an improved Siri that understood context, knew what was happening across apps and got tasks done was a highlight. Apple repeatedly pushed the release back, citing engineering issues and bugs. TechCrunch says the delay eventually contributed to a $250 million settlement over claims about how Apple marketed the AI capabilities of the iPhone 16. Siri AI appeared in the iOS 27 beta this past July, and the AI-powered version is rolling out to English-language users first this month, with other languages expected to follow.
Character.ai gets the longest entry. Founded in 2021 by former Google researchers Noam Shazeer and Daniel De Freitas, it let people chat with customizable bots, many modeled on celebrities and fictional characters. It raised $150 million at a $1 billion valuation in 2023. The next year Google paid a reported $2.7 billion to license its technology and bring its founders back, leaving the startup to carry on without them. Trouble followed. Families sued, alleging the chatbots contributed to teen suicides and self-harm, and Disney sent a cease-and-desist letter over unauthorized use of its characters. Character.ai barred under-18 users from open-ended chats late last year and agreed, along with Google, to settle several of the suits in early 2026. It was not enough: the company filed for bankruptcy in early October, citing legal, regulatory and operational headwinds. Disney is now the opening bidder, offering $20 million for a license to some of the company's intellectual property. The app is still running during the process, and the sale is expected to wrap up by late November or early December.
The smaller shutdowns follow. Relay, an AI workflow automation tool built as an alternative to Zapier, shut down entirely in August 2026. It let users automate email and task workflows with AI agents, but as OpenAI, Google and other larger platforms built similar automation into their own tools, five-year-old Relay struggled to justify existing as a stand-alone product. Ollie launched in June 2026 as one of the first mainstream apps to achieve SOC 2, a privacy compliance standard. It was a family-focused agent that pulled together school messages, calendars, task lists and group chats, tracked reminders and household details, and delivered what mattered by text. It struggled to keep up with heavyweights like Muse and Instinct. Co-founder and CEO Bill Lennon said the app would shut down on November 6, citing inability to stand out, failure to grow and not raising enough capital.
Notion Mail launched in April 2025 as an AI-focused email product, but the company noticed its users were using separate AI agents to handle their inboxes instead. It is scheduled to shut down on September 22. Microsoft's Recall, announced at Build in 2024, was pitched as an AI "photographic memory" for Windows PCs that periodically took screenshots so users could search their own history. It triggered an immediate privacy and security backlash, with critics warning of a searchable archive of passwords, private messages and financial details. Microsoft delayed it for nearly a year to rethink protections. Even after the redesign, a cybersecurity researcher recently built a tool that could extract and display data Recall had captured, which revived questions about whether the underlying problem was fixed.
Two AI gadgets follow. The Humane AI Pin was meant to deliver AI through a wearable instead of a smartphone. Humane raised $230 million from investors, but the product struggled with performance, and the company warned customers to stop using its charging case over a potential battery fire risk. Humane shut down its AI Pin business in February 2025, and HP acquired most of its assets for $116 million. The Rabbit R1, unveiled at CES in January 2024, was designed to perform tasks for its owner, and Rabbit said it sold 100,000 units shortly after launch. Early reviews called it unfinished, with unreliable performance and few useful integrations. Rabbit has kept updating it, positioning it as a computer controller for agentic tasks, and recently announced a hardware project called "Project Cyberdeck", a portable device built for vibe-coding.
The list closes with three more. Huxe, an AI audio app from former developers of Google's NotebookLM that turned written information into podcast-style audio, shut down in May 2026, partly because larger platforms began offering similar experiences to big existing audiences; Spotify, for instance, has been expanding its own AI audio tools. Yupp, a free playground for comparing responses from hundreds of AI models side by side, let users vote and earn cryptocurrency, and at its peak offered more than 800 models from companies including OpenAI, Google and Anthropic. Its founders say it never reached strong enough product-market fit, and it shut down in March 2026. Figgs AI operated from 2023 to 2024, letting users create customizable AI characters for role-play and storytelling. It reportedly drew more than 1 million users, but its developers said keeping the service free became too expensive to sustain, and they shut it down.
Key facts
- Character.ai filed for bankruptcy in early October, five years after launch; Disney is the opening bidder at $20 million for a license to some of its IP, and the sale is expected to wrap up by late November or early December.
- Ollie, a family-focused AI agent launched in June 2026, shut down on November 6, with CEO Bill Lennon citing inability to stand out, failure to grow and too little capital.
- OpenAI rolled back its July 9 ChatGPT "super app" redesign, discontinued ChatGPT Atlas on August 9, folded Operator into ChatGPT, and shut Sora in March 2026.
- Apple's repeated Siri AI delays contributed to a $250 million settlement over iPhone 16 AI marketing claims; the new Siri is rolling out to English-language users first this month.
- TechCrunch cites S&P Global Market Intelligence: about 42% of AI initiatives are ultimately abandoned by their corporate parents.
Why it matters
The list puts a number and a long run of cases on a pattern: AI products fail often, and not only at small startups. S&P Global Market Intelligence's figure is that about 42% of AI initiatives are ultimately abandoned by their corporate parents. The cases show recurring causes. Larger platforms built similar features into their own tools (Relay, Huxe), users preferred separate AI agents (Notion Mail), and costs were too high to sustain (Sora, Figgs AI). Even OpenAI, one of the most valuable private companies in the world, had to roll back a redesign and retire several stand-alone apps.
Who it affects
Founders and product teams building AI apps that a bigger platform could absorb as a feature. Investors weighing consumer AI bets. Users of the affected products: Character.ai's app is still running during the bankruptcy process, while Ollie, Relay, Notion Mail, Yupp and Huxe have closed or are scheduled to. Buyers of AI hardware such as the Humane AI Pin and Rabbit R1 are part of the story too, as are Apple customers waiting on the new Siri.
How to use it
Treat it as a reference list of what went wrong and why. A reader can check a product idea against the failure reasons TechCrunch names: insufficient funding, technical challenges, competition, difficulty scaling, weak user demand, or a larger platform shipping the same thing. Anyone depending on an AI tool can use the shutdown dates here as a prompt to plan for exports and alternatives. The article gives no instructions beyond this.
How solid is it
This is a TechCrunch compilation of events, mostly drawn from the companies' own announcements and earlier reporting. Some figures are flagged as uncertain in the text: Google's $2.7 billion payment for Character.ai's technology is described as "reported", Figgs AI's 1 million users as "reportedly", and the 100,000 Rabbit R1 units is Rabbit's own claim. The Yupp and Ollie explanations come from the founders and the CEO. The text does not give a year for the July 9 ChatGPT update, the August 9 Atlas discontinuation or the September 22 Notion Mail shutdown. It does not say whether Disney's $20 million bid is accepted, and it does not say why OpenAI shut down Operator or give a date for it.
Risks and caveats
The list mixes very different things: bankruptcies, hardware flops, rolled-back redesigns and features absorbed into other products. Not every entry is a failure in the same sense; the article itself calls folding Atlas and Operator into ChatGPT a strategy that worked out better than the redesign. Allegations against Character.ai, that its chatbots contributed to teen suicides and self-harm, come from suing families and are not established findings; the terms of the settlements are not given. Microsoft Recall is included for its controversy, and the source does not say it has been shut down. Rabbit is still updating the R1 and has announced a new project, so it is not dead either.
“The result is a growing AI graveyard.”
— TechCrunch