EFF and ACLU ask Sixth Circuit to require a warrant for ALPR searches

EFF, together with the ACLU, has filed an amicus brief in the Sixth Circuit court of appeals in United States v. Sturdivant. The case is one where police tracked a suspect's movements through Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) data without a warrant. EFF says its brief describes the vast, interconnected network of ALPRs that constantly track drivers around the country, and argues that this tracking is a "search" under the meaning of the Fourth Amendment.
The case involves a series of robberies in and around Cleveland, Ohio. From surveillance camera footage, police identified the make, model and color of the robber's car, but they did not know its license plate number. They then ran an open-ended search of two ALPR databases, Flock and ELSAG. The search showed that a car belonging to the defendant, Mr. Sturdivant, had been tracked near the sites of the robberies, and that eventually led to his arrest.
The defense moved to suppress the ALPR evidence. The district court held that Mr. Sturdivant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his license plate number, because members of the public could observe it. On that reasoning, he had no Fourth Amendment interest in not having his car tracked in public places.
EFF rejects the comparison: ALPRs, it says, are simply not comparable to observing an individual license plate on a passing car. It points to its many amicus briefs and to its own lawsuits challenging ALPR use in San Jose, California and Wisconsin, where it has explained that ALPRs give law enforcement "a virtual time machine to view suspects', or anyone else's, past movements (and much more) with just the click of a button." EFF also notes that just last month a federal district court agreed and held that ALPRs are a "form of indiscriminate mass surveillance" that can violate the Fourth Amendment.
EFF's stated hope is that the Sixth Circuit will reverse the lower court in this case and hold that ALPR searches require a warrant.
Key facts
- EFF and the ACLU filed an amicus brief in the Sixth Circuit in United States v. Sturdivant, arguing that warrantless ALPR tracking is a Fourth Amendment "search".
- Police knew only the make, model and color of the robber's car from camera footage, then ran an open-ended search of two ALPR databases, Flock and ELSAG, which led to the defendant's arrest.
- The district court held the defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his license plate number because the public could observe it.
- EFF says that last month a federal district court held ALPRs to be a "form of indiscriminate mass surveillance" that can violate the Fourth Amendment.
- EFF hopes the Sixth Circuit will reverse and hold that ALPR searches require a warrant.
Why it matters
The district court's reasoning treats a license plate as something anyone can see, so tracking a car in public raises no Fourth Amendment issue. EFF argues that this misses what ALPRs do: they work as a network that constantly tracks drivers and lets police look back at past movements with a click. If the Sixth Circuit accepts EFF's view, a warrant would be required before police run searches like the one in Sturdivant. EFF also says a federal district court recently took its side on the broader question.
Who it affects
Any driver whose plate is captured by an ALPR network, since EFF describes the network as constantly tracking drivers around the country. It also affects police departments that search ALPR databases such as Flock and ELSAG, and defendants who want to challenge evidence gathered that way. The case itself arises from robberies in and around Cleveland, Ohio.
How to use it
This is a court filing, not a product. The practical use is to follow the Sixth Circuit's handling of Sturdivant, and to note the argument EFF makes: that ALPR searches are Fourth Amendment searches and need a warrant. Lawyers and advocates can also see the cases EFF cites as its other work on the issue, its lawsuits in San Jose, California and Wisconsin.
How solid is it
The account comes from EFF, a party to the argument, and it describes the district court's ruling and the facts of the case in its own words. The case facts are specific: two named ALPR databases, a car identified by make, model and color, a motion to suppress, and a district court ruling. The source presents the appeal as undecided, since EFF only says it hopes the Sixth Circuit will reverse.
Risks and caveats
EFF's brief is advocacy, and the outcome is open. The source does not give a calendar date for the filing, for the Sixth Circuit's schedule or for a decision. It also does not name the district court that ruled against Sturdivant or the one that ruled last month, does not say whether Sturdivant was convicted or what charges he faced, and does not describe the status of EFF's lawsuits in San Jose and Wisconsin.
“a virtual time machine to view suspects’, or anyone else’s, past movements (and much more) with just the click of a button.”
— EFF, on what ALPRs give law enforcement