NYC Council passes ban on surveillance pricing, fines up to $1,000

The New York City Council passed a bill on a Thursday that bans companies in the city from using surveillance pricing. The bill defines the practice as charging different prices based on algorithms or shoppers' personal data, such as demographics, credit, browsing history or purchasing history. It covers both online and in-store sales, although the practice is mainly used on the web.
Under the bill, the city could issue fines of up to $1,000 for each transaction that violates the ban.
Speaker Julie Menin, whose proposal it is, called surveillance pricing an "insidious and predatory corporate practice" that erodes privacy and fairness. At a press conference ahead of the vote she said it worsens the affordability crisis and that the Council was going to end it.
The Council pointed to one investigation as an example. Target shoppers saw prices jump based on location data showing whether they were inside or outside a store: a 55-inch SmartTV cost $499 on the Target app inside a store and $599 in the store parking lot. Uber, Lyft, Target, Instacart and airlines are among the companies that have faced scrutiny for alleged surveillance pricing. Many of them have denied using the practice.
Menin's proposal follows legislation approved by Albany lawmakers in June that prohibits surveillance pricing online and in stores, with some exceptions.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said in a statement that he supports the ban. He called surveillance pricing "just another way corporations are finding to squeeze working people" and added that New Yorkers' personal data should never be used as a weapon against their own pocketbooks.
Business groups have warned that the ban could hinder discounts or loyalty programs. Josh Gold, a spokesperson for Uber, said that if enacted the law will make it harder for small restaurants with limited marketing budgets to reach customers, putting them at a disadvantage against national chains. Uber operates Uber Eats, which lets restaurants offer discounts based on search history and previous orders. Menin said the legislation would not affect discounts.
Key facts
- The City Council passed a bill banning surveillance pricing in New York City: different prices based on algorithms or personal data such as demographics, credit, browsing history or purchasing history.
- The ban applies online and in stores; the city could fine violators up to $1,000 per transaction.
- In an investigation cited by the Council, a 55-inch SmartTV cost $499 on the Target app inside a store and $599 in the parking lot.
- The bill follows state legislation approved by Albany lawmakers in June; Mayor Zohran Mamdani says he supports the ban.
- Business groups and Uber warn it could hinder discounts and loyalty programs; Speaker Julie Menin says discounts will not be affected.
Why it matters
The bill takes a practice, personalised pricing built on personal data, and makes it a finable offence in New York City. The Council's own example is concrete: the same TV at $499 inside a Target store and $599 in its parking lot, driven by location data. The city measure follows state legislation from June that also prohibits the practice online and in stores, with some exceptions.
Who it affects
Companies selling to New Yorkers, online and in stores, are covered. Uber, Lyft, Target, Instacart and airlines are among those that have faced scrutiny for alleged surveillance pricing, and many have denied using it. Shoppers are the people the bill is meant to protect. Small restaurants come up in Uber's objection: its spokesperson says the law would make it harder for them to reach customers.
How to use it
This is a law rather than a product, so there is nothing to switch on. The practical points from the bill: it prohibits prices set from personal data such as demographics, credit, browsing history or purchasing history, it applies both online and in stores, and the city can fine each violating transaction up to $1,000. Companies that run personalised offers are the ones with something to check.
How solid is it
The report comes from Gothamist and describes an official Council vote, with named officials quoted. The Target price gap is attributed to an investigation cited by the Council; the source does not name who conducted it. The vote count, the date the ban takes effect and whether the mayor has signed it are not stated; Mamdani only said he supports the ban.
Risks and caveats
The main dispute is over discounts. Business groups warn the ban could hinder discounts or loyalty programs, and Uber points to Uber Eats, where restaurants can offer discounts based on search history and previous orders. Menin says the legislation would not affect discounts. Many companies named in the scrutiny deny using surveillance pricing at all. The state law carries some exceptions, which the source does not spell out.
“It's a practice that worsens the affordability crisis, and today it's a practice that we are going to be ending”
— Julie Menin, Speaker of the City Council, at a press conference ahead of the vote